The Pittsburgh Pirates are facing a critical challenge at third base, and one player’s unexpected rise could be the solution they’ve been searching for. With Opening Day looming, the Pirates find themselves short on options at the hot corner, leaving fans and analysts alike wondering who will step up. Enter Enmanuel Valdez, a player whose journey to third base is as intriguing as it is unconventional. But here’s where it gets interesting: Valdez, primarily known for his time at second base, is now being groomed as the backup third baseman, despite limited major league experience at the position. Could this be the Pirates’ secret weapon, or a risky gamble? Let’s dive in.
Jared Triolo is the frontrunner to start at third base on Opening Day, but the Pirates’ lack of depth at the position has forced them to explore unconventional solutions. Valdez, who has spent most of his major league career at second base, is now being prepped for a potential role at third. According to Colin Beazley of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Valdez has been taking infield drills at third base, signaling a shift in his responsibilities. But why Valdez? And this is the part most people miss: while he’s only started one game at third base in the majors, he boasts an impressive 139 starts at the position in the minors. That experience could prove invaluable, especially if Triolo faces injury or the Pirates fail to secure additional talent before the season begins.
Here’s the controversial part: Valdez’s defensive metrics at second base have been underwhelming, with a minus-11 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) and Outs Above Average (OAA). Does this make him a liability at third base, or is there untapped potential waiting to be unlocked? The Pirates seem willing to take the risk, but it’s a move that has sparked debate among fans and analysts alike.
The Pirates’ third base dilemma is further complicated by the lack of viable alternatives. Jack Brannigan, the only other true third baseman on the 40-man roster, is recovering from a season-ending torn labrum and has yet to play at Triple-A. Nick Gonzales and Nick Yorke have minimal experience at third, leaving Valdez as the most realistic option. But is he ready for the challenge?
Valdez’s journey to this point has been anything but straightforward. Acquired from the Boston Red Sox in December 2024 in exchange for pitcher Joe Vogatsky, Valdez made his Pirates debut in March 2025 after Nick Gonzales suffered a season-ending ankle injury on Opening Day. Primarily playing first base due to injuries to Endy Rodríguez and Spencer Horwitz, Valdez appeared in 31 games, slashing .209/.294/.363 with two home runs and 12 RBI. However, his season was cut short by a left shoulder injury that required surgery, sidelining him for six months. After a successful rehab stint in the Dominican and Puerto Rican Winter Leagues, Valdez is now back and ready to contribute—but at third base?
The bigger question remains: Can Valdez make the transition smoothly, or will the Pirates’ third base woes persist? His minor league experience at third base is promising, but the jump to the majors is no small feat. And let’s not forget the elephant in the room—his defensive struggles at second base. Is this a case of necessity breeding innovation, or are the Pirates setting themselves up for disappointment?
As the Pirates prepare for the upcoming season, Valdez’s role at third base could be a defining factor in their success. Whether you see this as a stroke of genius or a desperate move, one thing is clear: all eyes will be on Valdez as he steps into this unexpected spotlight. What do you think? Is Valdez the answer to the Pirates’ third base problem, or are they better off exploring other options? Let us know in the comments below!
For the latest updates, insights, and analysis on the Pittsburgh Pirates, be sure to visit Pirates OnSI (https://www.si.com/mlb/pirates/onsi). The season is just getting started, and you won’t want to miss a moment of the action!
